By choosing to continue, you are consenting to the use and functioning of this site as is in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

ORIGINAL THINKING
find an article

 
PRINT | |

ENSight

 

28 Nov 2025
BY Dr. Bernard Dippenaar

Tammy Taylor vs The Viljoens - Trade marks take centre stage...again

The nail world has once again collided with Intellectual Property ("IP") and it is getting spicier than a fresh acrylic set.

First, a quick recap

Peet and Melany Viljoen once operated Tammy Taylor South Africa under a licence from Tammy Taylor Nails Incorporated in the US. As licensees, they were authorised to use the Tammy Taylor brand only for as long as the licence remained in force - a fundamental principle in trade mark law. That relationship ended, but the Viljoens reportedly continued to trade under the brand.

The U.S. judgment – Ownership matters

In mid-2025, the U.S. District Court (Southern District of California) ruled that the Viljoens:

  • Infringed Tammy Taylor’s registered trade marks
  • Breached the license agreement
  • Must pay ZAR71 million in statutory damages
  • Must stop all use of Tammy Taylor names/logos/domains
  • Must remove every reference to the brand from stores and social media

No defence was seemingly filed, and the judgment was granted by default. Textbook trade mark enforcement usually follows once a licence is terminated, as all authorisation to use the brand falls away. Continued use = infringement.

Plot twist: The Viljoens now sue Tammy Taylor

The Viljoens now claim their original licence was “illegal” and argue that: You cannot license a trade mark if you do not manufacture the goods, and they are suing Tammy Taylor for USD200 million (ZAR3.4 billion).

But here’s the trade mark reality:

  • A trade mark is not a manufacturing certificate.
  • It is a badge of origin indicating that goods/services are supplied under the control of the trade mark owner.
  • Nike, Mercedes, Apple - none need to manufacture their own goods to own or license their trade marks.

Some incorrect claims made publicly by the Viljoens:

 “You cannot license something you don’t manufacture.” False. Licensing relies on control, not manufacturing.

“Anyone can use the name ‘Mercedes’, just not the logo.” False. Word marks are trade marks too - Mercedes owns the word.

“If Tammy Taylor didn’t register in South Africa first, she can’t claim ownership.” Misleading. The register shows various SA marks in the name of Tammy Taylor Inc., and any prior assignments or licence terms control ownership rights. Exported reputation of well-known marks can also offer protection.

Where this appears to be heading

 The courts in the US and South Africa will be tasked to determine:

  1. Who owns the relevant trade marks in SA
  2. Whether the Viljoens’ ongoing use creates confusion
  3. Damages for continued infringement

As more filings land, expect trade mark law to decide the outcome.

Takeaway for businesses

If you license a brand:

  • Know what you own
  • Know what you are borrowing
  • Stop using the brand immediately when the licence ends

Otherwise, the bill may make your gel polish cure early.

Dr Bernard Dippenaar

Senior Associate | Intellectual Property 

bdippenaar@ENSafrica.com